Shop Notes

Right-leaning news outlets less critical of Trump, study shows

Posted: Oct. 6, 2017 | Tags: journalism

Donald Trump

Photo by Gage Skidmore, Flickr

Donald Trump at the 2011 Conservative Political Action Conference in Washington.

News outlets with politically right-leaning audiences produce more positive evaluations of the Trump administration in their stories but cite fewer sources and are less critical of the administration, according to a new Pew Research Center report. 

Pew analyzed 3,000 news stories for this study from 24 media outlets, including television, radio and online, produced during Trump’s first 100 days — from Jan. 21 to April 30. Pew’s methodology states that qualifying stories were defined as articles that were at least 50 percent about Trump and/or his administration. Specified editorial or opinion sections or segments were not included, but individual opinion stories not set apart in a designated opinion section were included. The study looked at media across TV networks, cable, radi, digital and print platforms. (Digital had the largest left-leaning audience and radio had the largest right-leaning audience.)

"An outlet was classified as left-leaning if its audience included at least two-thirds more liberal Democrats than conservative Republicans,” Senior Researcher Jeffrey Gottfried said in an email interview. 

The same goes for the classification of right-leaning outlets, he said. 

Gottfried said Pew has studied the news coverage of U.S. presidents since Bill Clinton in 1993, and the purpose of this study was to find similarities and differences in today’s media coverage of Trump.

“The public’s choice in their news media has large implications on the information that they will receive on any storyline,” Gottfried said. “While roughly the same topics were covered across outlets, the voices they heard from, the assessments they got about the president and the administration and the extent to which they heard challenges to the president’s words differed.”

One of the key conclusions of the study that Gottfried pointed out is that fewer stories focused on policy and more were negative compared to presidential coverage in the past. 

Only 31 percent of stories analyzed Trump’s policy agenda compared to 50 percent for Barack Obama; 65 percent for George W. Bush; and 58 percent for Bill Clinton in each of their respective first 60 days. 

Right-leaning audience outlets were five times more likely to report a positive evaluation of Trump’s words or actions compared to stories from the left-leaning or mixed-audience outlets. 

And Gottfried said journalists from left-leaning audience outlets were about seven times more likely to refute a statement by the president or his administration in their stories compared to right-leaning outlets. 

The report said that left-leaning audience outlets cite the most types of sources. About 70 percent of their stories contain two or more different source types. However, a little more than half of the stories from right-leaning audience outlets carried neither a positive nor a negative assessment of Trump.

Recent Posts

Editors: 'We are not at war with Trump'

Top editors of two of the country’s leading news organizations said that their reporters were at the forefront of covering the Trump administration, but they were not competing with each other to topple the presidency.

Dean Baquet and Marty Baron, executive editors of The New York Times and The Washington Post, respectively, said that a journalist’s mission of pursuing truth and fairness hasn’t changed in the Trump era.

Behind the Post's opioids investigation

Graduate student and Workshop intern Reis Thebault was a contributing reporter to a recent Washington Post investigation into congressional action that many in the Drug Enforcement Agency saw as hampering their efforts to stem the opioid crisis.

King hoped to enlighten Kennedy on civil rights

The Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. tried to influence John F. Kennedy in his run for president because he saw Kennedy as far removed from the realities of blacks in America, according to a new book on the relationship between the two powerful men. 

 Subscribe to the RSS Feed



Follow the workshop at IRWorkshop